Long Island vs Cat Island: Remote Bahamas Out Islands Compared
Long Island and Cat Island represent the far reaches of Out Island travel in the Bahamas, offering solitude and natural beauty for travelers willing to venture beyond the more accessible destinations. Both islands reward those seeking unpopulated beaches and genuine escape from crowds.
Long Island stretches roughly 80 miles with dramatic white cliffs, hidden caves, and Dean's Blue Hole, the world's second deepest. Cat Island is even more rustic and remote, with rolling hills reaching the highest point in the Bahamas and a spiritual, contemplative atmosphere that draws visitors seeking true solitude.
| Long Island | Cat Island | |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Two airports with several more flights than Cat Island make it easier to reach. Still remote by most standards but more connected to Nassau. | Very limited air traffic makes getting there more challenging. Getting between Cat Island and Long Island is difficult without returning through Nassau. |
| Infrastructure | More nice homes scattered on the island with more resorts and lodgings that include dining options. Still limited but better developed than Cat Island. | Very rustic with little tourist infrastructure. Accommodations are few and services are basic. True off-grid character. |
| Remoteness | Remote and quiet but with enough infrastructure for comfortable travel. A middle ground between developed islands and true wilderness. | The most deserted feeling of the major Out Islands. Especially recommended for travelers who love unpopulated areas. |
| Beaches | Beautiful ocean-facing beaches plus lee side beaches. White cliffs, caves, and cool coves add variety. Atlantic side beaches are particularly scenic. | Ocean-facing beaches on both sides similar in quality to Long Island. Fewer dramatic geological features but equally beautiful sand and water. |
| Natural attractions | Dean's Blue Hole is the signature attraction, drawing freedivers from around the world. White cliffs provide dramatic scenery unlike other Bahamas islands. | Mount Alvernia at 206 feet is the highest point in the Bahamas, topped by a hermitage built by Father Jerome. Rolling hills create unusual Bahamas landscape. |
| Getting around | One main road runs the length of the island but is in bad shape in places. Getting around takes longer than distances suggest. Car rental essential. | Similarly requires a rental car for exploration. Limited road infrastructure but the island is smaller and easier to navigate overall. |
Our recommendation
Choose Long Island if you want dramatic scenery including Dean's Blue Hole and white cliffs with somewhat better accessibility and accommodation options. It offers a genuine remote experience without requiring complete self-sufficiency. Choose Cat Island if you seek maximum solitude and do not mind very limited infrastructure. Cat Island suits travelers who find spiritual appeal in its hills and hermitage, or simply want the most unpopulated Out Island experience available.
Frequently asked questions
- Can you visit both Long Island and Cat Island on one trip?
- It is difficult without returning to Nassau since there is little air traffic between the two islands. Most travelers choose one destination for their trip.
- Which island is better for diving?
- Long Island offers Dean's Blue Hole, the world's second deepest blue hole, making it a pilgrimage site for freedivers. Both islands have good reef diving but Long Island has the signature attraction.
- Are there restaurants on Cat Island and Long Island?
- Long Island has several restaurants associated with lodgings. Cat Island has very few dining options, and visitors should be prepared to be more self-sufficient with food.
Still deciding?
Tell us your priorities and we'll plan the perfect Abacos charter for you.
Plan your charterMore Bahamas comparisons.