Deadman's Cay

Hamilton's Cave

The crown attraction near Deadman's Cay is Hamilton's Cave, the largest known cave system in the Bahamas. Located on private land in nearby Hamilton's Settlement, the cave requires guided tours arranged through the Cartwright family, who have owned the property since 1847 when they purchased it from the English Crown.

The cave passages reach 50 feet wide in places with ceilings rising 10 feet or more. Tours reveal Lucayan Indian artifacts including pottery, tools, and animal bones left centuries ago. Different bat species inhabit the cave, and the guide shares the geological history of stalactite and stalagmite formation. Contact Leonard Cartwright in advance to arrange your visit.

Gateway Services

Deadman's Cay Airport (LGI) serves as the more accessible of Long Island's two airports, with daily Bahamasair flights from Nassau. The runway expansion project announced in 2025 will extend the strip to accommodate larger jets, potentially transforming Long Island's accessibility in coming years.

The settlement itself provides essential services visitors need. Grocery stores stock provisions unavailable in smaller settlements, banking services are available, and car rentals can be arranged through local contacts. It lacks the scenic charm of Clarence Town or the resort amenities of Stella Maris, but serves a vital practical function.

Exploring the Central Island

Deadman's Cay occupies a central position on Long Island, making it a practical base for exploring in multiple directions. Dean's Blue Hole lies roughly 20 minutes south, while Stella Maris and Cape Santa Maria are 30-40 minutes north. This centrality, combined with better shopping options, appeals to visitors planning extended stays.

The surrounding area includes several smaller settlements named for founding families, offering glimpses into Long Island's history. Mangrove Bush, known for traditional boat building, lies to the north, while various plantation ruins dot the landscape, remnants of the cotton and slave economy that shaped the island's early colonial period.

Getting there

Deadman's Cay Airport (LGI) receives daily Bahamasair flights from Nassau, with a flight time of approximately 40 minutes. The airport sits adjacent to the settlement. Rental cars should be arranged in advance through your accommodation or local contacts, as no major rental agencies operate on the island. Queen's Highway runs through Deadman's Cay, connecting to Stella Maris (30 minutes north) and Clarence Town (20 minutes south).

Frequently asked questions

How do I arrange a Hamilton's Cave tour?

Contact Leonard Cartwright, whose family has owned the cave since 1847. Look for the CAVE TOUR sign on a building in Hamilton's Settlement along Queen's Highway. Tours require advance reservation and cost approximately $15 for adults and $8 for children.

Should I fly into Deadman's Cay or Stella Maris?

Deadman's Cay Airport has more frequent flights and better connects to Nassau. However, if you're staying at Cape Santa Maria or Stella Maris Resort, the northern Stella Maris Airport may be more convenient. Check flight schedules for both when planning.

Is Deadman's Cay a good place to stay overnight?

While Deadman's Cay offers practical services, most visitors prefer the resort amenities of Stella Maris or the architectural charm of Clarence Town for overnight stays. Deadman's Cay works best as a provisioning stop and gateway rather than a destination.