Preacher's Cave
The birthplace of the Bahamas — where shipwrecked Puritans found shelter and held the islands' first services.
Preacher's Cave is where the story of the modern Bahamas begins. In 1648, a group of English Puritans fleeing religious persecution in Bermuda — the Eleutheran Adventurers — shipwrecked on the Devil's Backbone reef off Eleuthera's northern tip. The survivors took shelter in this sea cave, where they carved a pulpit from the rock and held regular services.
The cave opens onto Tay Bay Beach, a long sweep of pale pink sand that remains one of the quietest and most beautiful beaches on the island.
The Eleutheran Adventurers
Led by William Sayle, a former governor of Bermuda, the Adventurers sought religious freedom in the New World. Their ship struck the reef in a storm, forcing them ashore with little more than the clothes on their backs. The cave became their church, meeting hall, and refuge as they established the first permanent European settlement in the Bahamas.
Archaeological excavations have uncovered skeletal remains of both the Adventurers and earlier Lucayan-Taino inhabitants, underscoring the site's layered history.
The cave & rock pulpit
Preacher's Cave is a wide, shallow sea cave with a sandy floor and a natural rock formation that the Adventurers shaped into a pulpit. For over a century, annual services commemorated their survival here.
The cave is now protected and open to visitors. A simple wooden cross marks the site, and information panels tell the story. The scale is modest — the power lies in the history it represents.
Tay Bay Beach & Devil's Backbone
Immediately outside the cave, Tay Bay Beach stretches for miles — soft, pale pink sand backed by palm groves and casuarinas. The water is calm and shallow, perfect for swimming and wading. You may have the entire beach to yourself.
Offshore lies the Devil's Backbone, the same reef that wrecked the Adventurers' ship. Today it is a renowned snorkelling and diving site, its shallow coral gardens teeming with fish and the remains of several historic wrecks.
Getting there
Preacher's Cave is about 10 miles from North Eleuthera Airport. Take the Queen's Highway north, then follow signs toward The Bluff and the cave. A rental car is essential. The road ends at a small parking area near Tay Bay Beach; the cave is a short walk from there.
Frequently asked questions
- Who were the Eleutheran Adventurers?
- A group of English Puritans who fled religious persecution in Bermuda in 1648, led by William Sayle. They shipwrecked on Eleuthera and established the first permanent European settlement in the Bahamas, taking shelter in Preacher's Cave.
- Can you swim at Preacher's Cave?
- The cave itself is not for swimming, but Tay Bay Beach lies just outside — a beautiful stretch of calm, shallow water perfect for swimming, wading, and snorkelling.
- What is the Devil's Backbone?
- A shallow coral reef off North Eleuthera that has wrecked ships for centuries, including the Adventurers' vessel in 1648. Today it is a popular snorkelling and diving site with coral gardens and historic wrecks.
Nearby
Harbour Island
Three miles of pink sand, pastel colonial charm, and the Caribbean's most coveted barefoot luxury.
ExplorePink Sands Beach
Three miles of blush-coloured sand and Atlantic rollers on the Bahamas' most photographed shore.
ExploreSpanish Wells
A 17th-century fishing village where lobster boats still outnumber tourists and time moves at its own pace.
Explore